MODULE B · P2B02

Appraisal and Assesement of Credit Facilities

3428 manuscript words25 original MCQsDated sources and verification notes included
Chapters and chapter contents
100%
Practise this chapter ↓

Last updated · By the Clerk2Officer editorial team · Report a correction

Credit appraisal

Credit appraisal1. ApplicationUse the buttons for explanation2. FinancialsUse the buttons for explanation3. Cash flowsUse the buttons for explanation4. RiskUse the buttons for explanation5. StructureUse the buttons for explanation6. SanctionUse the buttons for explanation

Capture the complete proposal and end use.

Appraisal and Assesement of Credit Facilities

Chapter P2B02 · Module B · Principles and Practices of Banking

1. Appraisal converts a request into a reasoned decision

Credit appraisal is the structured examination of a borrowing proposal to determine whether the bank should take the exposure and, if so, on what terms. Assessment of the amount is one part of appraisal. A mathematically correct working-capital limit can still be inappropriate if the business is fictitious, the borrower lacks authority or the repayment assumptions are unrealistic.

  • Assessment of amount is one component of the broader appraisal decision.

The process should connect purpose, need, repayment, risk and structure. The borrower may ask for a round amount because it feels sufficient, but the bank should derive the requirement from evidence. It should also consider whether the proposed facility solves the real problem. A permanent operating loss cannot normally be cured by repeatedly increasing a short-term limit.

  • Derive borrowing need from evidence; a larger short-term limit does not cure permanent losses.

The appraisal output should explain:

  • the borrower and business model;
  • the purpose and assessed funding need;
  • the primary repayment source;
  • the important risks and mitigants;
  • the proposed facility, security and conditions;
  • the assumptions that monitoring must later test.
2. Information and due diligence

Useful information includes constitutional and authority documents, financial statements, bank-account conduct, tax or transaction records where relevant, projections, business contracts, existing debt and security details. The purpose is not to collect the largest possible file. It is to obtain reliable evidence for the decision and resolve material inconsistencies.

  • Collect decision-relevant evidence and resolve material inconsistencies.

Historical financial statements show what has happened; projections describe an expected future. Neither should be accepted uncritically. A sudden increase in projected sales should be supported by capacity, orders, market demand and working-capital implications. A borrower's explanation that “sales will double” is not enough if machinery, labour and distribution remain unchanged.

  • Projected growth needs support from capacity, demand and the resources required to deliver it.

Due diligence should examine:

  • legal identity, ownership and authorised borrowing;
  • promoter experience, conduct and financial contribution;
  • actual operations and end use;
  • existing liabilities and contingent commitments;
  • customer and supplier concentration;
  • related-party transactions and unusual cash movements;
  • consistency across financial and operating evidence.
3. Technical, commercial, managerial and financial appraisal

Technical appraisal examines whether the proposed activity can be implemented and operated with the available technology, location, inputs, utilities and skills. Commercial appraisal examines demand, competition, pricing and the ability to sell and collect. Managerial appraisal concerns competence, governance and execution capacity. Financial appraisal examines cost, funding, profitability, cash flow and debt service.

  • Technical, commercial, managerial and financial appraisals examine different but connected dimensions.

These dimensions interact. A technically efficient plant may fail commercially if customers will not buy its output. A profitable forecast may be impossible to implement because a critical approval or utility connection is missing. A strong market may still produce losses if management cannot control quality, inventory or collections.

  • A proposal must work across implementation, market, management and financial assumptions.

The credit note should make these links visible. Instead of writing “management satisfactory,” explain the relevant experience and any gaps. Instead of “market good,” identify the demand evidence and concentration risk. A conclusion is useful when a reviewer can see why it follows from the facts and what would change it.

  • A credit note should connect its conclusions to evidence and identifiable risks.
4. Reading financial statements for lending

The balance sheet shows assets and funding at a point in time. The income statement reports performance over a period. Cash-flow analysis explains movements in cash and funding. Profit is not the same as cash available for repayment: credit sales can increase profit while receivables absorb cash, and inventory accumulation can consume funds before sales occur.

  • Profit differs from cash available for repayment; receivables and stock can absorb funds.

A lender should adjust for quality. An old receivable may be less liquid than its accounting classification suggests. An advance to a related party may not be available for routine operations. A large cash balance on the year-end date may be temporary. The analysis should consider trends and average or peak positions, not only a convenient reporting date.

  • Asset quality, trends and normal balances matter beyond a reporting-date snapshot.

Important questions include:

  • Are profits recurring or driven by one-off items?
  • Are receivables collecting within the expected period?
  • Is inventory usable and saleable?
  • Have long-term funds financed long-term assets adequately?
  • Are liabilities complete, including guarantees and other commitments?
  • Does cash generation support debt service after essential needs?
5. Ratios: indicators, not automatic verdicts

A current ratio compares current assets with current liabilities. A debt-equity measure compares the selected debt definition with the selected equity base. Interest coverage compares an earnings measure with interest. Each ratio depends on definitions and accounting quality. Two analysts can produce different results if one includes current maturities or adjusts intangible assets and the other does not.

  • State ratio definitions because changes in numerator or denominator change the result.

For teaching, state the formula and assumptions. If current assets are ₹80 lakh and current liabilities ₹50 lakh, the current ratio is 1.60. That does not prove liquidity if ₹30 lakh of receivables are uncollectible. After excluding those receivables, the adjusted ratio becomes ₹50 lakh/₹50 lakh = 1.00. Asset quality changes the interpretation.

  • The example’s current ratio falls from 1.60 to 1.00 after excluding uncollectible receivables.

Do not present a single current-ratio or debt-equity number as an RBI-mandated pass mark for every borrower. Historical methods and bank policy may use benchmarks, but the applicable framework and business context must be established. Ratios are starting points for questions, not substitutes for cash-flow analysis.

  • No single ratio is a universal pass mark for every borrower.
6. Working capital and the operating cycle

Gross working capital refers to current assets used in operations. Net working capital is current assets minus current liabilities under the stated accounting definition. For bank assessment, distinguish other current liabilities from bank borrowing so that the same bank finance is not deducted and then added inconsistently.

  • Net working capital is current assets less current liabilities under the stated definition.

The operating cycle follows cash through purchases, production, inventory, sales and collection. Supplier credit delays the cash outflow and reduces the period that must be financed. A simplified cash-conversion cycle is inventory days plus receivable days minus payable days. Longer inventory or collection periods usually increase funding need; longer sustainable supplier credit can reduce it.

  • The simplified cash cycle equals inventory days plus receivable days minus payable days.

Example: Assume inventory days 50, receivable days 40 and payable days 30. The simplified cash cycle is 60 days. If relevant annual cash operating cost is ₹3.65 crore and a 365-day year is assumed, daily cost is ₹1 lakh. A rough cycle-based funding estimate is ₹60 lakh. This is a simplified illustration; actual assessment should use the appropriate cost bases for each component and avoid valuing every asset at sales value.

  • The assumed cycle is 60 days; ₹1 lakh daily cost gives a ₹60 lakh rough requirement.
7. Turnover method

The traditional turnover illustration assesses working-capital need at 25% of projected annual turnover, with a borrower contribution of 5% of turnover and bank finance of 20%. RBI's historical guidance and MSME FAQ explain the associated approach and emphasise appraisal of genuine needs. [S1 to S2] Its applicability depends on borrower category, limit and current directions; it is not an unconditional entitlement for every applicant.

  • The traditional illustration uses 25% of turnover for need, split into 5% own funds and 20% bank finance.

Illustration: Assume the method applies and accepted projected turnover is ₹2 crore. Total assessed working-capital need is ₹50 lakh, borrower contribution ₹10 lakh and bank finance ₹40 lakh. The 5% and 20% are percentages of turnover, while the borrower provides one-fifth of the assessed ₹50 lakh requirement. Confusing those denominators is a common exam error.

  • On ₹2 crore turnover, the assumed method gives ₹50 lakh need, ₹10 lakh contribution and ₹40 lakh bank finance.

The bank must assess the projection. If claimed turnover is inflated to obtain a larger limit, the formula magnifies the error. Seasonal peaks, a longer cycle or unusual business structure may require additional analysis under the applicable policy. The method simplifies estimation; it does not eliminate credit judgment.

  • An assessment formula magnifies errors in unrealistic sales projections.
8. Working-capital gap and historical MPBF methods

Let CA be eligible assessed current assets and OCL be other current liabilities excluding bank borrowing. Working-capital gap is CA minus OCL. Historical Tandon-style methods allocate part of that gap to long-term funds and the remainder to bank finance. They remain useful examination concepts, but the earlier rigid MPBF/current-ratio prescription was withdrawn, as recorded in RBI's historical circulars. [S3] Do not describe them as a universal current mandate.

  • Working-capital gap is eligible current assets less other current liabilities; historical MPBF methods are not universal current mandates.

Under the first teaching method, the borrower contributes 25% of the working-capital gap, so bank finance is 75% of that gap. Under the second, the borrower provides at least 25% of total current assets from long-term funds, and bank finance is 75% of CA minus OCL. The third historical approach additionally separates core current assets for long-term funding; it is a conceptual historical method, not a claim of general current adoption.

  • Method I applies 25% contribution to the gap; Method II applies it to total current assets.

Example: CA ₹100 lakh; OCL ₹20 lakh. Gap is ₹80 lakh. Method I bank finance is ₹60 lakh, with ₹20 lakh long-term contribution. Method II bank finance is ₹75 lakh − ₹20 lakh = ₹55 lakh, with ₹25 lakh contribution. The second method requires more long-term support because its 25% base is total current assets rather than the gap.

  • With CA ₹100 lakh and OCL ₹20 lakh, the illustrated bank finance is ₹60 lakh under I and ₹55 lakh under II.
9. Why the current ratio differs in the two examples

Using the preceding assumptions, Method I current liabilities are OCL ₹20 lakh plus bank finance ₹60 lakh = ₹80 lakh. Current ratio is 100/80 = 1.25. Under Method II, current liabilities are ₹20 lakh + ₹55 lakh = ₹75 lakh, so the ratio is 100/75 = 1.333…. This demonstrates how the historical 1.33 relationship arises from the assumptions.

  • Under the stated assumptions, the derived current ratios are 1.25 and approximately 1.33.

The derivation is more useful than memorising a number. If the data include additional current liabilities or the definitions change, the ratio may differ. Existing net working capital and the minimum required contribution must also be considered in a full assessment. A borrower already providing more long-term funds does not necessarily need the maximum formula result.

  • Formula results depend on definitions, liabilities and existing long-term support.

Exam steps:

  1. Identify current assets and eligible adjustments.
  2. Separate OCL from bank borrowing.
  3. Calculate the relevant gap.
  4. Apply the stated method and contribution base.
  5. Check the arithmetic against the funding balance.
  6. State that the result is an assessment subject to appraisal and sanction.
10. Cash-budget method

A cash budget estimates receipts and payments period by period. It is particularly useful when cash flows are seasonal, project-based or uneven. The required finance follows the peak cumulative deficit after considering opening cash, own funds and other committed sources. Annual profit alone cannot reveal that peak.

  • Cash-budget finance follows the peak cumulative deficit rather than annual profit alone.

Assume opening available cash is ₹5 lakh. Monthly net operating cash flows before financing are −₹8 lakh, −₹6 lakh, +₹4 lakh and +₹10 lakh. Cumulative balances before bank finance are −₹3 lakh, −₹9 lakh, −₹5 lakh and +₹5 lakh. The peak deficit is ₹9 lakh. If the assessment additionally requires a ₹2 lakh minimum cash buffer, the peak funding requirement becomes ₹11 lakh under these assumptions.

  • The peak deficit is ₹9 lakh; adding the assumed ₹2 lakh buffer gives ₹11 lakh.

The budget should not count uncertain receipts as guaranteed. Test collection timing, supplier payments, taxes, wages and capital expenditure. A large inflow after the peak does not remove the need to finance the earlier gap. Equally, a budget should show how the facility is repaid when receipts arrive rather than assume permanent utilisation.

  • Receipt timing determines both the temporary need for finance and the means of repayment.
11. Assessment is not drawing power

Assessment estimates the appropriate sanctioned need. Drawing power controls actual availability against eligible assets or other conditions at a particular time. A borrower may have an assessed ₹40 lakh limit but only ₹28 lakh drawing power because stocks and receivables are lower or partly ineligible. The sanction is not permission to draw beyond current permitted availability.

  • An assessed sanction does not permit drawal above current drawing power.

This distinction also prevents a common monitoring error. If the borrower submits an inflated stock statement, the problem is not solved by saying the original appraisal was sound. Current asset evidence and account conduct must be checked during operation. Conversely, a temporary seasonal reduction in utilisation is not automatically a sign that the original peak assessment was wrong.

  • Sound original appraisal does not validate a later inflated stock statement.

The credit note should connect assessment and operation: define eligible assets, margins, reporting frequency, permitted ageing, review conditions and actions for shortfall. Detailed operational rules are developed in B03, but the appraisal should anticipate what information can realistically be monitored.

  • Appraisal should specify asset eligibility, margins, information and shortfall controls.
12. Term-loan project cost and means of finance

Term-loan assessment begins with the total cost of the project or asset and the proposed sources of finance. Cost may include equipment, installation, civil work, implementation expenses, eligible interest during construction and working-capital margin as appropriate. The banker should avoid omitting necessary costs merely to make the proposal appear affordable.

  • Project cost should include all necessary and eligible implementation components.

Means of finance may include promoter equity, internal accruals, term debt and other valid committed sources. Each source should be verified for timing and availability. An unapproved subsidy or hoped-for investor is not the same as cash already committed. A funding gap during implementation can delay completion and reduce the project's ability to begin servicing debt.

  • Promoter funds and other finance must be available when required; an expected subsidy is not committed cash.

Example: Project cost is ₹120 lakh. Verified promoter contribution is ₹36 lakh and other committed eligible funding ₹12 lakh. The residual proposed term loan is ₹72 lakh. This calculation establishes the funding balance, not the final sanction: repayment capacity, eligibility, security and other risks still determine whether ₹72 lakh is appropriate.

  • ₹120 lakh cost less ₹36 lakh promoter funds and ₹12 lakh other funding leaves ₹72 lakh proposed debt.
13. Debt service coverage

Debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) compares cash available for debt service with the relevant principal and interest obligations. A common teaching formulation is (profit after tax + depreciation + term-loan interest)/(term-loan principal instalments + term-loan interest). The numerator adds back the interest included in the denominator to avoid an inconsistent comparison. Actual bank definitions may use cash accrual or cash available for debt service with further adjustments.

  • DSCR compares consistently defined cash available with principal and interest debt service.

Assume PAT ₹18 lakh, depreciation ₹6 lakh, term-loan interest ₹4 lakh and principal due ₹12 lakh. Under the stated formula, numerator is ₹28 lakh and denominator ₹16 lakh, so DSCR is 1.75. If PAT falls to ₹10 lakh with the other assumptions unchanged, DSCR becomes ₹20 lakh/₹16 lakh = 1.25. This sensitivity reveals a smaller cushion.

  • The example DSCR is 1.75, falling to 1.25 when PAT falls to ₹10 lakh.

An average DSCR can hide a weak year. Examine annual or period-specific coverage, seasonality and the minimum point. A moratorium can postpone principal but may increase later repayment pressure. The bank should not mechanically solve a weak project by pushing instalments beyond a realistic asset life.

  • Average DSCR can conceal a weak repayment period; inspect period-specific coverage.
14. Break-even, NPV and IRR

Break-even analysis estimates the sales level at which contribution covers fixed cost under stated assumptions. If fixed cost is ₹12 lakh and the contribution-to-sales ratio is 30%, break-even sales are ₹40 lakh. If expected sales are ₹60 lakh, the simple margin of safety is ₹20 lakh, or one-third of expected sales. Changes in price, variable cost or product mix can alter the result.

  • ₹12 lakh fixed cost divided by 30% contribution gives ₹40 lakh break-even sales.

Net present value discounts future cash flows at the selected rate and subtracts the investment. Positive NPV indicates that the forecast cash flows exceed the required return under those assumptions. IRR is the discount rate at which NPV is zero for the relevant cash-flow pattern. Neither measure guarantees that the forecast will occur, and unconventional cash flows can complicate IRR interpretation.

  • NPV depends on discounted forecast cash flows; IRR is a zero-NPV rate for the stated pattern.

One-period example: Invest ₹100 now and receive ₹115 after one year. At a 10% discount rate, NPV is 115/1.10 − 100 = ₹4.55 approximately; IRR is 15%. The lending decision still needs liquidity timing, debt-service capacity and downside analysis. Project attractiveness and the borrower's ability to meet a specific instalment schedule are related but not identical.

  • The one-year example gives approximately ₹4.55 NPV at 10% and a 15% IRR.
15. Sensitivity, stress and decision conditions

Sensitivity changes one assumption to show its effect; stress analysis may combine adverse changes. Useful variables include sales volume, selling price, input cost, collection delay, interest rate and implementation time. The objective is to identify vulnerabilities and an appropriate response, not to choose only mild shocks that preserve the desired sanction.

  • Sensitivity isolates an assumption; combined stress can reveal interacting vulnerabilities.

Suppose a business has adequate annual profit but a 30-day collection delay creates an additional ₹15 lakh cash gap. A term-loan DSCR may remain satisfactory while working-capital liquidity becomes strained. The response could involve tighter receivable control, a justified facility adjustment or more borrower funds. It should not automatically be an unsecured increase with no analysis.

  • A collection delay can strain working capital despite adequate annual profit or term-loan coverage.

A reasoned sanction can include conditions precedent to disbursement, staged release, promoter contribution, security perfection, insurance, reporting and financial covenants. Conditions should address identified risks and be capable of verification. A long list of generic clauses is not a substitute for a few well-designed controls tied to the proposal.

  • Sanction conditions should directly address identified risks and be verifiable.
16. Revision and appraisal discipline
  • Appraisal covers viability, authority and risk; amount assessment is one component.
  • Profit, cash flow and liquidity are different.
  • State ratio definitions and inspect asset quality.
  • Turnover percentages use different denominators from margin percentages.
  • Historical MPBF methods are learning tools, not a universal current mandate.
  • Cash budgets reveal peak deficits that annual figures conceal.
  • Term-loan funding balance must be supported by real sources.
  • DSCR should be examined by period and under adverse assumptions.
  • NPV and IRR depend on forecasts and do not replace debt-service analysis.
  • Sanction conditions should respond to specific risks and be monitored.

Illustrative DSCR calculation

Assume PAT, depreciation and term-loan interest define the stated numerator. This arithmetic does not establish credit eligibility.

LEARN THROUGH EXPLANATIONS

Chapter practice

This practice is separate from timed mock tests. Answers and explanations appear after you choose an option.

Your reading progress

Sign in to save your progress across devices.

Browse published timed tests for this paper