CLERK2OFFICER · CAIIB ABFM MODULE C

Other Non-DCF Valuation Models

2,519 teaching words · 25 explained questions

Module contents · Valuation calculation lab · Valuation worked cases

Review edition · 8 November 2026 · Academic review and UAT pending.

Relative valuation and its purpose

Relative valuation estimates value by comparing a business or security with market evidence for other businesses or securities. Instead of forecasting every future cash flow explicitly, the analyst asks how comparable claims are priced relative to a meaningful financial measure. The approach can be practical and informative, but its apparent simplicity should not conceal the judgement required to select and adjust the evidence.

A multiple is a ratio between a value measure and an operating or financial measure. Price-to-earnings relates equity price to equity earnings. Enterprise-value multiples relate an appropriately defined enterprise value to a compatible business measure. The numerator and denominator must describe consistent claims, periods and accounting boundaries. A ratio with mismatched inputs can look precise while having no useful economic interpretation.

Relative valuation does not establish that the whole market is correctly priced. If peers are unusually expensive or depressed, the resulting estimate can inherit that condition. Use the approach to understand market pricing and cross-check other evidence. Explain why the comparison is meaningful rather than treating a published sector average as a universal fair-value rule.

Match equity with equity measures

An equity multiple uses the value attributable to equity holders in its numerator and a measure attributable to the corresponding equity claim in its denominator. Ordinary-equity market capitalisation divided by earnings available to ordinary shareholders is a common example. At a per-share level, share price divided by compatible earnings per share gives the same multiple when the definitions and share basis agree.

Suppose ordinary shares trade at 120 and sustainable annual earnings per share are 10. The price-to-earnings ratio is 12 times. If a genuinely comparable business has sustainable earnings per share of 8 and a justified matching multiple of 12, the simple indicated share value is 96. The multiplication is easy; establishing comparability and sustainable earnings is the substantive work.

Earnings should be after the relevant interest, tax and preference claims where the numerator concerns ordinary equity. Using operating EBIT with ordinary market capitalisation skips financing and other claim differences. Similarly, a numerator including several equity classes should not be paired automatically with earnings belonging to only one class. Reconcile rights before applying the ratio.

Match the multipleEquity with equity metric; then Enterprise with operating metric; then Consistent periods and peersMatch the multiple1. Equity with equity metric2. Enterprise with operating metric3. Consistent periods and peers
Match the multiple: Equity with equity metric; Enterprise with operating metric; Consistent periods and peers.

Historical and forward earnings

A trailing multiple uses a defined historical earnings period, such as the latest twelve months. A forward multiple uses forecast earnings for a specified future period. Both can be useful, but they answer different questions. A forward multiple based on next year's profits should not be applied to last year's earnings without explaining the adjustment.

If a share price is 120, trailing earnings per share are 8 and next-year forecast earnings are 10, trailing P/E is 15 while forward P/E is 12. The share has not changed price; the denominator has changed. Comparing those ratios as if they described identical periods can produce a false conclusion about relative cheapness.

Record the price observation date and the information available at that date. A peer price from months ago combined with newly revised earnings can mix market conditions. Forecast quality matters especially for rapidly changing or cyclical businesses. Label forecasts and their source rather than presenting them as realised earnings.

Normalise the denominator

Reported profit can include asset-sale gains, unusual litigation costs or restructuring items. A normalisation exercise asks what earnings measure is suitable for the valuation purpose. Adjustments should be supported and applied consistently to the subject and comparables. A management label such as exceptional is not sufficient evidence that a cost will never recur.

Suppose reported ordinary earnings are 30, including a genuinely non-recurring after-tax gain of 6. Normalised earnings might be 24 under that assumption. Applying a multiple of 10 gives equity value of 240 rather than 300. The adjustment changes value materially, so the rationale and tax basis should be visible to the reviewer.

Do not remove costs simply because they make the business appear less attractive. Repeated restructuring, customer acquisition or maintenance expenditure may be economically necessary. Investigate whether the item is unusual, whether comparable firms incur similar costs and whether the forecast already handles it. Avoid deducting an item twice through both normalised earnings and a separate valuation adjustment.

Negative and low earnings

A conventional positive P/E multiple is difficult to interpret when earnings are zero or negative. Dividing by zero is undefined, and a negative ratio does not carry the usual meaning of years of earnings priced by the market. A tool should flag the limitation rather than rank a loss-making firm as automatically cheaper because its P/E is negative.

Low earnings can also create an unstable ratio. A small change in the denominator may produce a large movement in P/E even if market price barely changes. Determine whether low earnings reflect temporary disruption, a normal cyclical trough, heavy growth investment or a structurally weak business. Different causes require different analysis.

Possible alternatives include normalised earnings, enterprise measures, asset-based analysis or an explicit forecast of the transition to sustainable profitability. Each introduces assumptions that need support. Moving to a revenue multiple does not eliminate the need to understand margins, investment and future cash generation; it merely changes the immediate comparison measure.

Test the comparisonNormalise the denominator; then Review accounting and rights; then Explain the indicated rangeTest the comparison1. Normalise the denominator2. Review accounting and rights3. Explain the indicated range
Test the comparison: Normalise the denominator; Review accounting and rights; Explain the indicated range.

Price-to-book value

Price-to-book relates equity market value to a compatible accounting equity measure. It can be informative where book equity has economic relevance, but accounting policies, asset recognition and profitability influence the comparison. A low P/B ratio is not automatically evidence of undervaluation; it can reflect weak returns, asset-quality concerns or expected losses.

If ordinary-equity value is 600 and compatible book equity is 400, P/B is 1.5 times. Applying a justified 1.5 multiple to another firm's book equity of 300 gives an indicated equity value of 450. The exercise assumes that differences in returns, growth, risk and accounting have been considered, rather than that all firms deserve the same ratio.

For financial firms, book equity and returns on equity can be particularly relevant, but asset quality, provisioning, capital requirements and business mix require careful assessment. Negative book equity makes ordinary positive P/B comparisons problematic. Do not infer that deposits or all financial liabilities can be treated like incidental corporate borrowing in every valuation framework.

Enterprise-value multiples

Enterprise multiples seek to compare operating value with a compatible operating measure before the relevant financing claims. Common examples include EV/EBITDA and EV/EBIT. Define enterprise value carefully, including the treatment of debt, cash, leases, minority interests and other claims. Different data sources can use different conventions.

Suppose a supported EV/EBITDA multiple is 8 and normalised EBITDA is 50. Implied enterprise value is 400. With excess cash of 20 and debt of 100, and no other adjustments, equity value is 320. Dividing the enterprise value by ordinary shares directly would omit the debt and cash bridge and overstate ordinary value in this example.

EBITDA excludes depreciation and amortisation, but is not the same as cash flow. Capital expenditure, working-capital investment, taxes and other payments still matter. An asset-intensive business with large recurring replacement needs may look attractive on EBITDA while producing modest free cash flow. Compare capital intensity alongside the multiple.

EV/EBIT and revenue measures

EV/EBIT includes depreciation and amortisation in the operating earnings measure, which can make differences in asset consumption more visible than EBITDA. However, accounting depreciation policies, asset ages and acquisition-related amortisation can affect comparability. No single denominator automatically removes all accounting and economic differences.

A revenue multiple can be used where earnings are unstable or not yet positive, but it requires particular caution. Two firms with equal sales can have very different margins, retention, investment requirements and risk. A higher sales multiple may be justified by better economics, or may simply reflect an optimistic market assumption. Investigate rather than presume.

Suppose two businesses each have revenue of 100. One earns an operating margin of 20%, while the other earns 2%, with otherwise simplified assumptions. Applying an identical revenue multiple can conceal a major difference in operating profitability. A useful comparison explains the route from sales to sustainable cash flows, even if those flows are not explicitly discounted in the chosen market method.

Choose the comparable group

Relevant peers should resemble the subject in the factors that drive value: growth, profitability, risk, capital intensity, business mix, geography and scale. An industry label is a starting point, not a complete selection rule. A diversified conglomerate and a specialist operator can differ materially despite sharing one classification.

Document exclusions and adjustments so the peer set is not chosen merely to support a preferred price. A group containing only expensive firms while excluding equally relevant cheaper firms can bias the conclusion. Conversely, a business with a fundamentally different model may legitimately be excluded, but the reason should be economic and consistent.

Use enough evidence to understand dispersion, while recognising that a large weak peer set is not automatically better than a smaller relevant one. Inspect outliers individually. A very high ratio may result from a near-zero denominator, a one-time event or a genuinely different growth profile. A median can limit outlier influence but cannot repair incompatible definitions.

Trading and transaction evidence

Trading multiples usually reflect quoted prices for marketable interests at a stated date. Acquisition multiples reflect negotiated transactions that may include control, synergies and deal-specific terms. They are related evidence sources but should not be treated as identical. A transaction announcement may quote equity consideration, enterprise value or another headline figure.

Before calculating a transaction multiple, reconcile what the price includes. Debt assumed, cash acquired, contingent consideration and minority interests can change the numerator. Use a denominator on a consistent operating and time basis. An incomplete headline can materially distort the implied ratio.

Do not add a generic control premium to a transaction multiple that already reflects control without investigating overlap. Similarly, a buyer-specific synergy estimate should not be counted both in the chosen multiple and as a separate addition. Explain whether the purpose is stand-alone market value, investment value to a specific buyer or another stated basis.

Book value and adjusted assets

Book-value analysis starts with recognised assets and liabilities. Adjusted-net-asset analysis revisits their values on the selected premise and identifies material omitted obligations or assets. This can be useful for asset-holding businesses or as a cross-check, but recorded balances do not necessarily capture the full economics of a going concern.

Suppose book equity is 500. Property is supported at 120 above its carrying amount, receivables require a reduction of 30 and a further obligation of 40 is identified. Adjusted net assets are 550 before other relevant tax, transaction or premise-specific effects. Each adjustment requires evidence, and the same item must not be counted twice.

An operating business may derive value from customer relationships, processes and future earning capacity beyond separately saleable assets. Conversely, an asset's specialised use can limit its disposal value. Distinguish going-concern, replacement and liquidation assumptions. A sum of optimistic individual asset prices is not automatically a feasible sale value for the business.

Stock-and-debt approach

The stock-and-debt perspective aggregates the market values of identified financing claims. If ordinary shares have market value of 800 and debt market value is 300, the aggregate value of those claims is 1,100. Under an operating enterprise convention excluding excess cash of 100, operating enterprise value would be 1,000, assuming no other adjustments.

The debt market value may differ from its accounting carrying amount as interest rates and credit risk change. If debt is not traded, an estimation method and assumptions may be needed. Likewise, a thinly traded share price can provide less reliable evidence than an active market with relevant information. State the limitations of each observed or estimated claim value.

The approach is not simply another name for adding book equity and book debt. Market values, rights and the valuation date are central. Identify preferred shares, convertibles or other claims where material and treat them consistently with the chosen definition. A complete claim inventory helps avoid missing or double-counted interests.

A comparison range and decision use

Suppose suitable peers suggest an equity earnings multiple range from 10 to 14 and the subject's normalised ordinary earnings are 20. The simple indicated range is 200 to 280. This is a comparison range based on selected evidence, not a statistical confidence interval unless a justified statistical interpretation is provided separately.

Reconcile the range with the subject's strengths and weaknesses. Higher sustainable growth or returns may support a different position within the range, while concentration, weak controls or uncertain earnings may warrant caution. Quantified adjustments should have a basis; avoid arbitrary percentages selected only to reach an expected answer.

A valuation conclusion should explain the preferred measure, peer group, periods, normalisations and claim bridge. Cross-check against other appropriate approaches and investigate material differences. The goal is not to force all methods to agree, but to understand why their assumptions produce different indications and which evidence deserves the most weight.

Review checklist

Lease and consolidation consistency

Accounting changes can move expenses between operating costs, depreciation and financing without an equivalent change in the underlying business economics. Lease treatment is one example. If one company's EBITDA and enterprise value reflect lease liabilities while another's inputs use a different convention, their ratios may not be comparable. Reconcile both sides of the ratio rather than adjusting only the denominator.

Consolidation also affects the boundary. A group's operating earnings may include all of a controlled subsidiary even when the parent owns less than all its equity. The enterprise numerator should reflect the corresponding claims consistently, including any relevant non-controlling interest under the chosen definition. Alternatively, use a properly matched ownership basis throughout. Mixing full operating earnings with only part of the related capital value can distort the comparison.

These checks need not turn every introductory exercise into a complex accounting model. Where a question explicitly assumes no leases or minority interests, use that assumption. For real evidence, record what the source includes and identify material gaps. A clear simplification is more useful than an unexplained mixture of conventions.

Denominator selection as a business question

Choose a metric that relates meaningfully to how the business generates value. A subscription business may require attention to customer retention and servicing costs; a property owner may require asset and rental evidence; a manufacturer may require capital intensity and operating margins. A non-financial operating metric can provide context, but a price per user or customer is not automatically comparable across firms with very different monetisation and cost structures.

The existence of a quoted multiple does not establish that the metric is well defined. Check whether revenue is gross or net of pass-through amounts and whether users are active, paying or merely registered. Differences can be large enough to dominate the apparent valuation gap. A reliable comparison starts with definitions and economic meaning, then proceeds to arithmetic.

Use alternative denominators as diagnostic cross-checks. If the subject looks inexpensive on revenue but expensive on earnings, investigate margins and reinvestment rather than selecting whichever result seems attractive. The disagreement can reveal the very business issue the valuation needs to explain.

Label the numerator and denominator before calculating. Confirm whether each is equity or enterprise level, historical or forecast, consolidated or stand-alone, and expressed in matching units. Review unusual items, accounting differences and potential dilution. Record observation dates so another reviewer can reconstruct the comparison.

Finally, connect the result with the valuation purpose. A market multiple can support an estimate, but it does not determine whether a particular acquisition price creates value after financing, fees and integration. Relative valuation is strongest when its assumptions are transparent and its result is interpreted alongside the economics of the business.

Practice: 25 explained questions

Answers can be saved in this browser.

Choose answers, then check.

What is the main purpose of relative valuation?
Answer and explanation

A. Use comparable pricing evidence to estimate value on a consistent basis.

Relative valuation uses market comparisons but inherits their assumptions and conditions. Peer choice, definitions and economic similarity require judgement.

Which is an equity multiple?
Answer and explanation

A. Ordinary equity value divided by compatible ordinary earnings.

An equity multiple pairs equity value with a measure attributable to that claim. Enterprise operating measures require a different matched numerator.

Share price is 120 and compatible EPS is 10. What is P/E?
Answer and explanation

B. 12 times.

Divide price by earnings per share: 120/10 = 12. The earnings period and ordinary-share basis must match the stated comparison.

A supported P/E is 12 and subject EPS is 8. What is indicated price?
Answer and explanation

B. 96.

Apply the justified multiple to the compatible EPS: 12 × 8 = 96. This arithmetic does not itself validate the comparability assumption.

Price is 120, trailing EPS 8 and forecast EPS 10. What is trailing P/E?
Answer and explanation

D. 15.

Trailing P/E uses the historical denominator: 120/8 = 15. The forecast denominator would produce a different, forward ratio of 12.

With those same figures, what is forward P/E?
Answer and explanation

D. 12.

Forward P/E uses the specified forecast EPS of 10, giving 120/10 = 12. Do not compare it with a trailing ratio without acknowledging the different periods.

Reported ordinary earnings are 30, including a genuinely non-recurring after-tax gain of 6. What is normalised earnings under that assumption?
Answer and explanation

A. 24.

Removing the specified gain gives 30 − 6 = 24. The non-recurring judgement and tax basis should be supported and applied consistently.

At a multiple of 10, what value follows from those normalised earnings of 24?
Answer and explanation

B. 240.

Multiply the normalised compatible earnings by the supported multiple: 24 × 10 = 240. Using reported 30 would leave the unusual gain in the denominator.

Why not remove every cost labelled exceptional?
Answer and explanation

A. Some such costs recur or are economically necessary.

Normalisation needs economic evidence, not only a management label. Repeated restructuring or necessary acquisition spending may belong in sustainable performance.

What is the issue with a conventional P/E when earnings are zero?
Answer and explanation

A. The ratio is undefined.

Division by a zero denominator is undefined. Valuation may still be possible through another suitable method or supported future earnings analysis.

Why can a negative P/E be misleading as a cheapness ranking?
Answer and explanation

B. It lacks the usual positive-earnings interpretation.

A loss denominator changes the ratio's meaning. Investigate the cause and sustainability of losses rather than treating a more negative ratio as automatically cheaper.

Equity value is 600 and compatible book equity 400. What is P/B?
Answer and explanation

C. 1.5.

Price-to-book is 600/400 = 1.5. The accounting equity definition should correspond to the claim in the numerator.

Does low P/B automatically prove undervaluation?
Answer and explanation

B. No, it can reflect weak returns or asset-quality concerns.

Book-based ratios require context about profitability, risk and accounting quality. A low market valuation can reflect expected losses rather than mispricing.

EV/EBITDA is 8 and normalised EBITDA 50. What is implied enterprise value?
Answer and explanation

D. 400.

Multiply the compatible operating metric by the enterprise multiple: 50 × 8 = 400. It is not yet ordinary equity value.

If that EV is 400, excess cash 20 and debt 100, what is equity value with no other adjustments?
Answer and explanation

C. 320.

The simplified bridge is 400 + 20 − 100 = 320. Check that cash and debt treatment matches the operating valuation boundary.

Why is EBITDA not free cash flow?
Answer and explanation

C. Taxes, investment and working capital can still consume cash.

EBITDA omits material cash needs and non-cash expense effects. Capital intensity and other requirements matter when interpreting EBITDA-based comparisons.

What can EV/EBIT reflect that EBITDA excludes?
Answer and explanation

C. Depreciation and amortisation in operating earnings.

EBIT includes depreciation and amortisation, although accounting policies and asset ages can affect comparability. It is not automatically a perfect economic measure.

Why use revenue multiples cautiously?
Answer and explanation

C. Equal revenue can support very different margins and cash generation.

Revenue does not show the cost and reinvestment required to earn it. Compare margins, retention, capital needs and other business economics.

What makes a peer group useful?
Answer and explanation

B. Similarity in economically relevant value drivers.

Growth, profitability, capital intensity, risk and accounting definitions affect valuation. A classification label alone does not establish meaningful comparability.

What can a median multiple do?
Answer and explanation

A. Reduce outlier influence without repairing a poor peer set.

A median is a summary statistic. It can limit extreme observations' influence but cannot make mismatched businesses or definitions comparable.

Why distinguish trading from transaction multiples?
Answer and explanation

D. Control, synergy and deal terms can affect transaction evidence.

Quoted minority pricing and negotiated acquisitions may reflect different rights and conditions. Reconcile what the price includes before using it as evidence.

What is a danger of adding a generic control premium to a control-transaction multiple?
Answer and explanation

C. It may count control-related value twice.

A transaction multiple may already incorporate control effects. Additional premiums need support and should not duplicate benefits already embedded in the evidence.

Why reconcile lease treatment across peers?
Answer and explanation

A. Both enterprise value and operating metrics can be affected.

Accounting conventions can alter numerator and denominator. Adjusting only one side or mixing conventions can create an artificial valuation difference.

Aggregate stock value is 800, market debt 300 and excess cash 100. What is operating EV under the stated convention?
Answer and explanation

B. 1,000.

Aggregate claims are 1,100. Excluding excess cash of 100 gives operating EV of 1,000, assuming no other relevant adjustments.

What does a peer-multiple range of 10 to 14 applied to earnings 20 indicate?
Answer and explanation

D. A comparison range of 200 to 280 under the assumptions.

The range follows selected market evidence and normalised earnings. Its probability, feasibility and relevance require additional support rather than being implied by multiplication.

Sources and review

Original examples; independent academic review and website UAT pending.

Module contents · Valuation calculation lab · Valuation worked cases